MOVING ARBITRATION PROGRAM VS. SMALL CLAIMS COURT

Logo
Logo

Movers Arbitration Program VS Small Claims Court?

  1. What's the Difference?
  2. Can the Arbitrator Change My Valuation Coverage?
  3. What if a Moving Company Doesn't Have Arbitration?
  4. Arbitration is Better for Everyone
  5. ALL Companies Are Required By USDOT Law to Have Arbitration

1. What's the Difference?

Most shippers choose moving arbitration versus small claims court simply because filing paperwork for a court case can be difficult to understand, quite lengthy and expensive. Arbitration is the cheaper and faster alternative to going to small claims court, as an arbitrator is a median that settles disputes outside of the court system. A shipper must first allow the carrier the opportunity to settle their claim using their existing claims procedures, regardless of whether they would like to file for arbitration or for small claims court.

Arbitration for Movers

Once a carrier makes a settlement offer or denies the shipper’s claim, only then does the shipper have the option of filing for arbitration or small claims court. One of the major reasons that the arbitration program requirement became a law was because it helps prevent courtrooms from becoming backlogged with cases that can be settled through arbitration without occupying a courtroom. Furthermore, a judge could deny a court case if the shipper does not follow through with the company’s arbitration option.

2. Can the Arbitrator Change My Valuation Coverage?

One thing to keep in mind is that neither the arbitrator nor a judge can change the valuation coverage option that was selected by the shipper at the pickup location. Meaning that if the shipper elects for the free, sixty cents per pound per article coverage, that is the coverage that must apply to the claim, regardless of the situation. The same can be said for the full value protection and any applicable deductibles.

3. What If A Moving Company doesn't have Arbitration?

If a moving company fails to establish and maintain an active membership with an arbitration program, they may be subject to violations from the Department of Transportation which may also be accompanied by fines that are often times very costly. Moving Authority can help you be compliant with this legal requirement. The Moving Authority Household Goods Arbitration Program is a fair and easy process for carriers and their valued customers. With more than 75 lawyers and ex-judges who hold the legal authority to arbitrate on our panel, you will be compliant with all arbitration requirement regulations.
Moving Arbitration Vs. Small Claims Court

4. Arbitration Is Better for Everyone

There are many factors that come into play when a moving company and a client decide to do business together. Unfortunately, despite everyone’s best efforts to be professional and conduct great business, there are always hiccups along the way. Often times these problems lead to legal issues between the moving company and their clients, and there are many ways to go about handling such problems. The most common question is weighing Moving Arbitration Vs. Small Claims Court.


Moving Arbitration is always the best first step when dealing with a dispute instead of going directly to small claims court. Going to small claims court is a lengthy process that can also cost an arm and a leg for both parties. Court also involves stacks of legal paperwork that can be confusing and if filled out incorrectly it can slow the process down even further. Since the Department of Transportation (DOT) has taken note of how many cases sent to small claims court slow down the court system and how frequently they take place the DOT now requires all moving companies to have a moving arbitration program in place to legally operate their business. Because of this legal requirement if a client or a moving company tries to bypass their arbitration system and go directly to small claims court it may be thrown out by a judge before it is even heard. This is because small claims court should be the last step, only if the problem could really not be resolved by Arbitration. Remember that even though the moving company has purchased arbitration services, this is a neutral third party that is going to take a fair, legal and honest stance based on the facts at hand and helps each party come to an agreement.


It is important to note that neither an arbitrator nor a judge can change the valuation coverage that was previously agreed upon in the shipper/client contract. Going to court and bypassing the Arbitration will have no effect on this as it is legally binding.

5. ALL Companies Are Required By USDOT Law to Have Arbitration

Because all companies are required by law to have a moving arbitration program in place, and have that arbitration certificate displayed in a public place and renewed every year, operating your business without one is risky and could result in your company getting fined or even shut down if a client attempts to take you to court because you don’t have an arbitrator. The same goes for the customer; if you find a company operating without this, steer clear of them because it's most likely that isn’t the only place they have cut corners on in their business.

Comments

Avatar

Sarah

5 years, 5 months ago

How long do I have to file for arbitration?

Avatar

Jennifer

5 years, 5 months ago

If I file for arbitration, is the moving company required to pay me the amount awarded?

user avatar

Adam P

5 years, 5 months ago

Jennifer if you go into arbitration and the Arbitrator issues you an amount it is binding and the moving company is required to pay.

Avatar

Tammy

5 years, 5 months ago

If I signed a release form for the settlement amount but have not received the payment yet, can I file for arbitration to get the payment?

Avatar

Adam P

5 years, 5 months ago

If you have already signed a release form and agreed to a settlement amount, you are not able to file for arbitration. There is no laws that specify the time frame that a carrier must remit payment to you. If you have questions or issues regarding your payment, you should contact the moving company right away and inquire about the status. There may be a plausible explanation as to why you have not received the payment yet.

Add Comment

required

required (not published)

optional

Get A Free Quote

HOW CAN WE HELP

(888) 787-7813

support@movingauthority.com

08:00 AM - 21:00 PM

All moving companies that transport shipments across state lines are required by the department of transportation to maintain an active membership with a company that provides an arbitration program. Federal regulation code 49 CFR 375.211 provides a list of a minimum of 11 requirements that an arbitration program must meet: 

(1)
 The arbitration program must be provided in an unbiased manner. This means that neither party can have any special advantages over the other.

(2) Each shipper must be provided with information about the arbitration program that the carrier participates in before the carrier executes the order for service.

(3) If requested, the shipper must be provided all of the forms and or information necessary to initiate the arbitration process.

(4) The arbitration program must be able to ensure that each person authorized to arbitrate is unbiased toward both parties. The arbitrator must be able to obtain all information that is relevant to the dispute so that he or she may provide a prompt and fair decision making process.

(5) The arbitration program cannot charge the shipper more than half of the total arbitration cost. The arbitrator does however have the authority to determine the party that will be responsible for paying the arbitration costs. This includes any cost for initiating the arbitration proceedings.

(6) Neither the carrier nor the arbitration provider can require to participate in arbitration before a dispute arises. Meaning that you may not revoke the shipper’s right to file a claim using the carrier’s claims procedures.

(7) Any dispute submitted for arbitration must be binding if the claim is for $10,000.00 or less.

(8) If the shipper requests binding arbitration for claims exceeding $10,000.00 and the carrier agrees to it, then binding arbitration must be provided.

(9) An oral representation of a dispute can only be provided if both parties agree.

(10) An arbitration determination must be provided within 60 days from the date that the written notification of the dispute was provided. The decision made by the arbitrator can include any remedies appropriate given the circumstances of that individual dispute.

(11) Should either party fail to provide, in a timely manner, any information that the arbitrator determines to be reasonable, the arbitrator at his or her discretion may extend the 60-day period requirement for a reasonable period of time.

In 1895 Karl Benz designed and built the first truck in history by using the internal combustion engine. Later that year some of Benz's trucks gave into modernization and went on to become the first bus by the Netphener. This would be the first motor bus company in history. Hardly a year later, in 1986, another internal combustion engine truck was built by a man named Gottlieb Daimler. As people began to catch on, other companies, such as Peugeot, Renault, and Bussing, also built their own versions. In 1899, the first truck in the United States was built by Autocar and was available with two optional horsepower motors, 5 or 8.

Prior to the 20th century, freight was generally transported overland via trains and railroads. During this time, trains were essential, and they were highly efficient at moving large amounts of freight. But, they could only deliver that freight to urban centers for distribution by horse-drawn transport. Though there were several trucks throughout this time, they were used more as space for advertising that for actual utility. At this time, the use of range for trucks was quite challenging. The use of electric engines, lack of paved rural roads, and small load capacities limited trucks to most short-haul urban routes.

A commercial driver's license (CDL) is a driver's license required to operate large or heavy vehicles.

Beginning the the early 20th century, the 1920's saw several major advancements. There was improvement in rural roads which was significant for the time. The diesel engine, which are 25-40% more efficient than gas engines were also a major breakthrough. We also saw the standardization of truck and trailer sizes along with fifth wheel coupling systems. Additionally power assisted brakes and steering developed. By 1933, all states had some form of varying truck weight regulation.

In 1976, the number one hit on the Billboard chart was "Convoy," a novelty song by C.W. McCall about a convoy of truck drivers evading speed traps and toll booths across America. The song inspired the 1978 action film Convoy directed by Sam Peckinpah. After the film's release, thousands of independent truck drivers went on strike and participated in violent protests during the 1979 energy crisis (although similar strikes had occurred during the 1973 energy crisis).

In the United States, shipments larger than about 7,000 kg (15,432 lb) are classified as truckload freight (TL). It is more efficient and affordable for a large shipment to have exclusive use of one larger trailer. This is opposed to having to share space on a smaller Less than Truckload freight carrier.

In 1978 Sylvester Stallone starred in the film "F.I.S.T.". The story is loosely based on the 'Teamsters Union'. This union is a labor union which includes truck drivers as well as its then president, Jimmy Hoffa.

The moving industry in the United States was deregulated with the Household Goods Transportation Act of 1980. This act allowed interstate movers to issue binding or fixed estimates for the first time. Doing so opened the door to hundreds of new moving companies to enter the industry. This led to an increase in competition and soon movers were no longer competing on services but on price. As competition drove prices lower and decreased what were already slim profit margins, "rogue" movers began hijacking personal property as part of a new scam. The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) enforces Federal consumer protection regulations related to the interstate shipment of household goods (i.e., household moves that cross State lines). FMCSA has held this responsibility since 1999, and the Department of Transportation has held this responsibility since 1995 (the Interstate Commerce Commission held this authority prior to its termination in 1995).

Trailer stability can be defined as the tendency of a trailer to dissipate side-to-side motion. The initial motion may be caused by aerodynamic forces, such as from a cross wind or a passing vehicle. One common criterion for stability is the center of mass location with respect to the wheels, which can usually be detected by tongue weight. If the center of mass of the trailer is behind its wheels, therefore having a negative tongue weight, the trailer will likely be unstable. Another parameter which is less commonly a factor is the trailer moment of inertia. Even if the center of mass is forward of the wheels, a trailer with a long load, and thus large moment of inertia, may be unstable.

The United States' Interstate Highway System is full of bypasses and loops with the designation of a three-digit number. Usually beginning with an even digit, it is important to note that this pattern is highly inconsistent. For example, in Des Moines, Iowa the genuine bypass is the main route. More specifically, it is Interstate 35 and Interstate 80, with the loop into downtown Des Moines being Interstate 235. As it is illustrated in this example, they do not always consistently begin with an even number. However, the 'correct' designation is exemplified in Omaha, Nebraska. In Omaha, Interstate 480 traverses the downtown area, which is bypassed by Interstate 80, Interstate 680, and Interstate 95. Interstate 95 then in turn goes through Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Furthermore, Interstate 295 is the bypass around Philadelphia, which leads into New Jersey. Although this can all be rather confusing, it is most important to understand the Interstate Highway System and the role bypasses play.

The United States Department of Transportation has become a fundamental necessity in the moving industry. It is the pinnacle of the industry, creating and enforcing regulations for the sake of safety for both businesses and consumers alike. However, it is notable to appreciate the history of such a powerful department. The functions currently performed by the DOT were once enforced by the Secretary of Commerce for Transportation. In 1965, Najeeb Halaby, administrator of the Federal Aviation Adminstration (FAA), had an excellent suggestion. He spoke to the current President Lyndon B. Johnson, advising that transportation be elevated to a cabinet level position. He continued, suggesting that the FAA be folded or merged, if you will, into the DOT. Clearly, the President took to Halaby's fresh ideas regarding transportation, thus putting the DOT into place.

The Federal Bridge Gross Weight Formula is a mathematical formula used in the United States to determine the appropriate gross weight for a long distance moving vehicle, based on the axle number and spacing. Enforced by the Department of Transportation upon long-haul truck drivers, it is used as a means of preventing heavy vehicles from damaging roads and bridges. This is especially in particular to the total weight of a loaded truck, whether being used for commercial moving services or for long distance moving services in general.   According to the Federal Bridge Gross Weight Formula, the total weight of a loaded truck (tractor and trailer, 5-axle rig) cannot exceed 80,000 lbs in the United States. Under ordinary circumstances, long-haul equipment trucks will weight about 15,000 kg (33,069 lbs). This leaves about 20,000 kg (44,092 lbs) of freight capacity. Likewise, a load is limited to the space available in the trailer, normally with dimensions of 48 ft (14.63 m) or 53 ft (16.15 m) long, 2.6 m (102.4 in) wide, 2.7 m (8 ft 10.3 in) high and 13 ft 6 in or 4.11 m high.

In the moving industry, transportation logistics management is incredibly important. Essentially, it is the management that implements and controls efficiency, the flow of storage of goods, as well as services. This includes related information between the point of origin and the point of consumption to meet customer's specifications. Logistics is quite complex but can be modeled, analyzed, visualized, and optimized by simulation software. Generally, the goal of transportation logistics management is to reduce or cut the use of such resources. A professional working in the field of moving logistics management is called a logistician.

In 1986 Stephen King released horror film "Maximum Overdrive", a campy kind of story. It is really about trucks that become animated due to radiation emanating from a passing comet. Oddly enough, the trucks force humans to pump their diesel fuel. Their leader is portrayed as resembling Spider-Man's antagonist Green Goblin.

The 1950's were quite different than the years to come. They were more likely to be considered "Knights of the Road", if you will, for helping stranded travelers. In these times truck drivers were envied and were viewed as an opposition to the book "The Organization Man". Bestseller in 1956, author William H. Whyte's novel describes "the man in the gray flannel suit", who sat in an office every day. He's describing a typical office style job that is very structured with managers watching over everyone. Truck drivers represented the opposite of all these concepts. Popular trucking songs glorified the life of drivers as independent "wanderers". Yet, there were attempts to bring back the factory style efficiency, such as using tachnographs. Although most attempts resulted in little success. Drivers routinely sabotaged and discovered new ways to falsify the machine's records.

The Federal-Aid Highway Amendments of 1974 established a federal maximum gross vehicle weight of 80,000 pounds (36,000 kg). It also introduced a sliding scale of truck weight-to-length ratios based on the bridge formula. Although, they did not establish a federal minimum weight limit. By failing to establish a federal regulation, six contiguous in the Mississippi Valley rebelled. Becoming known as the "barrier state", they refused to increase their Interstate weight limits to 80,000 pounds. Due to this, the trucking industry faced a barrier to efficient cross-country interstate commerce.

Some trailers can be towed by an accessible pickup truck or van, which generally need no special permit beyond a regular license. Such examples would be enclosed toy trailers and motorcycle trailers. Specialized trailers like an open-air motorcycle trailer and bicycle trailers are accessible. Some trailers are much more accessible to small automobiles, as are some simple trailers pulled by a drawbar and riding on a single set of axles. Other trailers also have a variety, such as a utility trailer, travel trailers or campers, etc. to allow for varying sizes of tow vehicles.

Words have always had a different meaning or have been used interchangeably with others across all cultures. In the United States, Canada, and the Philippines the word "truck" is mostly reserved for larger vehicles. Although in Australia, New Zealand, and South Africa, the word "truck" is generally reserved for large vehicles. In Australia and New Zealand, a pickup truck is usually called a ute, short for "utility". While over in South Africa it is called a bakkie (Afrikaans: "small open container"). The United Kingdom, India, Malaysia, Singapore, Ireland, and Hong Kong use the "lorry" instead of truck, but only for medium and heavy types.

Heavy trucks. A cement mixer is an example of Class 8 heavy trucks. Heavy trucks are the largest on-road trucks, Class 8. These include vocational applications such as heavy dump trucks, concrete pump trucks, and refuse hauling, as well as ubiquitous long-haul 6×4 and 4x2 tractor units. Road damage and wear increase very rapidly with the axle weight. The axle weight is the truck weight divided by the number of axles, but the actual axle weight depends on the position of the load over the axles. The number of steering axles and the suspension type also influence the amount of the road wear. In many countries with good roads, a six-axle truck may have a maximum weight over 50 tons (49 long tons; 55 short tons).