MOVING ARBITRATION PROGRAM VS. SMALL CLAIMS COURT

Logo
Logo

Movers Arbitration Program VS Small Claims Court?

  1. What's the Difference?
  2. Can the Arbitrator Change My Valuation Coverage?
  3. What if a Moving Company Doesn't Have Arbitration?
  4. Arbitration is Better for Everyone
  5. ALL Companies Are Required By USDOT Law to Have Arbitration

1. What's the Difference?

Most shippers choose moving arbitration versus small claims court simply because filing paperwork for a court case can be difficult to understand, quite lengthy and expensive. Arbitration is the cheaper and faster alternative to going to small claims court, as an arbitrator is a median that settles disputes outside of the court system. A shipper must first allow the carrier the opportunity to settle their claim using their existing claims procedures, regardless of whether they would like to file for arbitration or for small claims court.

Arbitration for Movers

Once a carrier makes a settlement offer or denies the shipper’s claim, only then does the shipper have the option of filing for arbitration or small claims court. One of the major reasons that the arbitration program requirement became a law was because it helps prevent courtrooms from becoming backlogged with cases that can be settled through arbitration without occupying a courtroom. Furthermore, a judge could deny a court case if the shipper does not follow through with the company’s arbitration option.

2. Can the Arbitrator Change My Valuation Coverage?

One thing to keep in mind is that neither the arbitrator nor a judge can change the valuation coverage option that was selected by the shipper at the pickup location. Meaning that if the shipper elects for the free, sixty cents per pound per article coverage, that is the coverage that must apply to the claim, regardless of the situation. The same can be said for the full value protection and any applicable deductibles.

3. What If A Moving Company doesn't have Arbitration?

If a moving company fails to establish and maintain an active membership with an arbitration program, they may be subject to violations from the Department of Transportation which may also be accompanied by fines that are often times very costly. Moving Authority can help you be compliant with this legal requirement. The Moving Authority Household Goods Arbitration Program is a fair and easy process for carriers and their valued customers. With more than 75 lawyers and ex-judges who hold the legal authority to arbitrate on our panel, you will be compliant with all arbitration requirement regulations.
Moving Arbitration Vs. Small Claims Court

4. Arbitration Is Better for Everyone

There are many factors that come into play when a moving company and a client decide to do business together. Unfortunately, despite everyone’s best efforts to be professional and conduct great business, there are always hiccups along the way. Often times these problems lead to legal issues between the moving company and their clients, and there are many ways to go about handling such problems. The most common question is weighing Moving Arbitration Vs. Small Claims Court.


Moving Arbitration is always the best first step when dealing with a dispute instead of going directly to small claims court. Going to small claims court is a lengthy process that can also cost an arm and a leg for both parties. Court also involves stacks of legal paperwork that can be confusing and if filled out incorrectly it can slow the process down even further. Since the Department of Transportation (DOT) has taken note of how many cases sent to small claims court slow down the court system and how frequently they take place the DOT now requires all moving companies to have a moving arbitration program in place to legally operate their business. Because of this legal requirement if a client or a moving company tries to bypass their arbitration system and go directly to small claims court it may be thrown out by a judge before it is even heard. This is because small claims court should be the last step, only if the problem could really not be resolved by Arbitration. Remember that even though the moving company has purchased arbitration services, this is a neutral third party that is going to take a fair, legal and honest stance based on the facts at hand and helps each party come to an agreement.


It is important to note that neither an arbitrator nor a judge can change the valuation coverage that was previously agreed upon in the shipper/client contract. Going to court and bypassing the Arbitration will have no effect on this as it is legally binding.

5. ALL Companies Are Required By USDOT Law to Have Arbitration

Because all companies are required by law to have a moving arbitration program in place, and have that arbitration certificate displayed in a public place and renewed every year, operating your business without one is risky and could result in your company getting fined or even shut down if a client attempts to take you to court because you don’t have an arbitrator. The same goes for the customer; if you find a company operating without this, steer clear of them because it's most likely that isn’t the only place they have cut corners on in their business.

Avatar

Sarah

4 years, 8 months ago

How long do I have to file for arbitration?

Avatar

Jennifer

4 years, 8 months ago

If I file for arbitration, is the moving company required to pay me the amount awarded?

user avatar

Adam P

4 years, 8 months ago

Jennifer if you go into arbitration and the Arbitrator issues you an amount it is binding and the moving company is required to pay.

Avatar

Tammy

4 years, 8 months ago

If I signed a release form for the settlement amount but have not received the payment yet, can I file for arbitration to get the payment?

Avatar

Adam P

4 years, 8 months ago

If you have already signed a release form and agreed to a settlement amount, you are not able to file for arbitration. There is no laws that specify the time frame that a carrier must remit payment to you. If you have questions or issues regarding your payment, you should contact the moving company right away and inquire about the status. There may be a plausible explanation as to why you have not received the payment yet.

Add Comment

required

required (not published)

optional

Did You Know

Question

The trucking industry has made a large historical impact since the early 20th century. It has affected the U.S. both politically as well as economically since the notion has begun. Previous to the invention of automobiles, most freight was moved by train or horse-drawn carriage. Trucks were first exclusively used by the military during World War I.
 
After the war, construction of paved roads increased. As a result, trucking began to achieve significant popularity by the 1930's. Soon after trucking became subject to various government regulation, such as the hours of service. During the later 1950's and 1960's, trucking accelerated due to the construction of the Interstate Highway System. The Interstate Highway System is an extensive network of freeways linking major cities cross country.

Question Beginning the the early 20th century, the 1920's saw several major advancements. There was improvement in rural roads which was significant for the time. The diesel engine, which are 25-40% more efficient than gas engines were also a major breakthrough. We also saw the standardization of truck and trailer sizes along with fifth wheel coupling systems. Additionally power assisted brakes and steering developed. By 1933, all states had some form of varying truck weight regulation.

Question In 1976, the number one hit on the Billboard chart was "Convoy," a novelty song by C.W. McCall about a convoy of truck drivers evading speed traps and toll booths across America. The song inspired the 1978 action film Convoy directed by Sam Peckinpah. After the film's release, thousands of independent truck drivers went on strike and participated in violent protests during the 1979 energy crisis (although similar strikes had occurred during the 1973 energy crisis).

Question In the United States, shipments larger than about 7,000 kg (15,432 lb) are classified as truckload freight (TL). It is more efficient and affordable for a large shipment to have exclusive use of one larger trailer. This is opposed to having to share space on a smaller Less than Truckload freight carrier.

Question In 2009, the book 'Trucking Country: The Road to America's Walmart Economy' debuted, written by author Shane Hamilton. This novel explores the interesting history of trucking and connects certain developments. Particularly how such development in the trucking industry have helped the so-called big-box stored. Examples of these would include Walmart or Target, they dominate the retail sector of the U.S. economy. Yet, Hamilton connects historical and present-day evidence that connects such correlations.

Question Invented in 1890, the diesel engine was not an invention that became well known in popular culture. It was not until the 1930's for the United States to express further interest for diesel engines to be accepted. Gasoline engines were still in use on heavy trucks in the 1970's, while in Europe they had been entirely replaced two decades earlier.

Question As most people have experienced, moving does involve having the appropriate materials. Some materials you might find at home or may be more resourceful to save money while others may choose to pay for everything. Either way materials such as boxes, paper, tape, and bubble wrap with which to pack box-able and/or protect fragile household goods. It is also used to consolidate the carrying and stacking on moving day. Self-service moving companies offer another viable option. It involves the person moving buying a space on one or more trailers or shipping containers. These containers are then professionally driven to the new location.

Question The number one hit on the Billboard chart in 1976 was quite controversial for the trucking industry. "Convoy," is a song about a group of reckless truck drivers bent on evading laws such as toll booths and speed traps. The song went on to inspire the film "Convoy", featuring defiant Kris Kristofferson screaming "piss on your law!" After the film's release, thousands of independent truck drivers went on strike. The participated in violent protests during the 1979 energy crisis. However, similar strikes had occurred during the 1973 energy crisis.

Question The interstate moving industry in the United States maintains regulation by the FMCSA, which is part of the USDOT. With only a small staff (fewer than 20 people) available to patrol hundreds of moving companies, enforcement is difficult. As a result of such a small staff, there are in many cases, no regulations that qualify moving companies as 'reliable'. Without this guarantee, it is difficult to a consumer to make a choice. Although, moving companies can provide and often display a DOT license.

Question Business routes always have the same number as the routes they parallel. For example, U.S. 1 Business is a loop off, and paralleling, U.S. Route 1, and Interstate 40 Business is a loop off, and paralleling, Interstate 40.

Question Without strong land use controls, buildings are too often built in town right along a bypass. This results with the conversion of it into an ordinary town road, resulting in the bypass becoming as congested as the local streets. On the contrary, a bypass is intended to avoid such local street congestion. Gas stations, shopping centers, along with various other businesses are often built alongside them. They are built in hopes of easing accessibility, while home are ideally avoided for noise reasons.

Question “Writer-director James Mottern said he was influenced by nuanced, beloved movies of the 1970s such as "The Last Detail" and "Five Easy Pieces." Mottern said his female trucker character began with a woman he saw at a Southern California truck stop — a "beautiful woman, bleach blonde ... skin tanned to leather walked like a Teamster, blue eyes.” - Paul Brownfield

Question The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) is an agency within the United States Department of Transportation. The purpose of the FMCSA is to regulate safety within the trucking and moving industry in the United States. The FMCSA enforces safety precautions that reduce crashes, injuries, and fatalities involving large trucks and buses.

Question The term "lorry" has an ambiguous origin, but it is likely that its roots were in the rail transport industry. This is where the word is known to have been used in 1838 to refer to a type of truck (a freight car as in British usage) specifically a large flat wagon. It may derive from the verb lurry, which means to pull or tug, of uncertain origin. It's expanded meaning was much more exciting as "self-propelled vehicle for carrying goods", and has been in usage since 1911. Previously, unbeknownst to most, the word "lorry" was used for a fashion of big horse-drawn goods wagon.

Question The main purpose of the HOS regulation is to prevent accidents due to driver fatigue. To do this, the number of driving hours per day, as well as the number of driving hours per week, have been limited. Another measure to prevent fatigue is to keep drivers on a 21 to 24-hour schedule in order to maintain a natural sleep/wake cycle. Drivers must take a daily minimum period of rest and are allowed longer "weekend" rest periods. This is in hopes to combat cumulative fatigue effects that accrue on a weekly basis.

Question Relocation, or moving, is the process of vacating a fixed location, such as a residence or business, and settling in a different one. A move might be to a nearby location such as in the same neighborhood or a much farther location in a different city or even a different country. Moving usually includes packing up all belongings, transferring them to the new location, and unpacking them. It will also be necessary to update administrative information. This includes tasks such as notifying the post office, changing registration data, change of insurance, services etc. It is important to remember this step in the relocation process. 

Question In 1893, the Office of Road Inquiry (ORI) was established as an organization. However, in 1905 the name was changed to the Office Public Records (OPR). The organization then went on to become a division of the United States Department of Agriculture. As seen throughout history, organizations seem incapable of maintaining permanent names. So, the organization's name was changed three more times, first in 1915 to the Bureau of Public Roads and again in 1939 to the Public Roads Administration (PRA). Yet again, the name was later shifted to the Federal Works Agency, although it was abolished in 1949. Finally, in 1949, the name reverted to the Bureau of Public Roads, falling under the Department of Commerce. With so many name changes, it can be difficult to keep up to date with such organizations. This is why it is most important to research and educate yourself on such matters.

Question Unfortunately for the trucking industry, their image began to crumble during the latter part of the 20th century. As a result, their reputation suffered. More recently truckers have been portrayed as chauvinists or even worse, serial killers. The portrayals of semi-trailer trucks have focused on stories of the trucks becoming self-aware. Generally, this is with some extraterrestrial help.

Question Commercial trucks in the U.S. pay higher road taxes on a State level than the road vehicles and are subject to extensive regulation. This begs the question of why these trucks are paying more. I'll tell you. Just to name a few reasons, commercial truck pay higher road use taxes. They are much bigger and heavier than most other vehicles, resulting in more wear and tear on the roadways. They are also on the road for extended periods of time, which also affects the interstate as well as roads and passing through towns. Yet, rules on use taxes differ among jurisdictions.